Sunday, January 24, 2010

Can a jury in a civil case ignore the law and can that case be appealed? what about for a criminal case?

Please explain as thoroughly as possible.Can a jury in a civil case ignore the law and can that case be appealed? what about for a criminal case?
No and Yes





A jury can not rule on matters of law. Only on matters of fact. As it happens juries will occasionally forget this and try to change the law. This is called jury nullification. If it is obvious they were doing this a judge will usually set aside the jury verdict and issue a different judgment. If not, the case can be appealled. Remember that the winner in a jury trial is given the benefit of assuming all of the facts are true during appeal. This means only issues of law can be appealed.





Can a jury in a civil case ignore the law and can that case be appealed? what about for a criminal case?
Yes


Yes


Same as above

No comments:

Post a Comment